Epic Chowder Smackdown: Old school fish shop takes top honor

Chowder CCarol Lollis | Daily Hampshire Gazette

Schermerhorn’s Seafood Restaurant clam chowder, Holyoke Score: 4.5 Price: cup, $3.99; bowl, $4.99

The judges found this chowder deliciously creamy and well-balanced.

Amanda: Everything a clam chowder should be. You could actually smell the clams.

Kristin: The clams were soft and the creamy potato mixed nicely. Buttery fishy goodness.

Lou: A little gritty, but not too gritty. This is a very classic clam chowder done well.

Cal’s Wood-Fired

Grill & Bar clam chowder, West Springfield Score: 3.9 Price: $5

This one surprised the judges with its powerful and complex notes of cheese — Gruyere? Amanda found it “confusing,” but most enjoyed it quite a bit.

Lou: Creamy and clammy, with a good depth of flavor. It felt elegant. Not quite funky, but almost. I mean that in a good way.

Hunter: Not sure that I’d eat a big bowl of it, but it’s surprising and nicely aromatic.

James: I kept wondering if the Swiss had invaded. This one doesn’t work for me.

Smithsonian Cafe and Chowderhouse seafood chowder, Northampton and Hatfield Score: 2.8 Price: cup, $4.25; bowl, $5.50

The panel wasn’t wowed with this soup, citing a sturdy flavor profile, but finding the texture a bit off-putting.

Kristin: Listless. Tastes mass-produced. My chopped veggies are tiny.

Lou: I expect this kind of chowder to be served in most places. It’s not bad, and it’s fairly spiced, but it’s so-so.

Hunter: My clams had a good consistency. I liked that it was on the thicker side. It’s a workman-like chowder.

#5: Captain Jack’s Roadside Shack clam chowder, Easthampton Score: 2.75 Price: cup, $3.25; bowl, $6

This chowder stood out for its bacon — with mixed results.

Amanda: I like bacon, but the bacon overpowers this one. It was pretty much the only thing I could taste.

Lou: Underseasoned, and I couldn’t taste any clams. It could have been a potato chowder for all I know.

James: The upfront salt detracted from the other flavors. Too chewy. This one had a challenging clam.

Ocean Grill & Steakhouse clam chowder, Greenfield Score: 2.5 Price: cup, $4.50; bowl, $5.95

This divisive concoction had some judges patting their bellies and some judges bemused by the balance of flavors.

Kristin: Too fishy.

Pete: Deliciously salty. Almost grimy. Tasted authentic, with a decent amount of clams.

James: Bacon! Land animals don’t belong in chowder.

#6: Paul & Elizabeth’s Restaurant seafood chowder, Northampton Score: 2.2 Price: cup, $3; bowl $4.25

This beach-bummer scored lowest and left the panel unimpressed.

Hunter: The fish was overcooked, and the soup itself is flat and bland. It’s like they forgot to season it.

Kristin: It’s trying too hard to let the fish be the star, but it needs more supporting characters. Simple is not best in this case.

Pete: I did get lots of veggies and a decent amount of fish, so that’s good. I would still add bacon.•

 Photos by 
 Carol Lollis

Author: Hunter Styles Photos by Carol Lollis

Share This Post On
  • Richard Tebaldi

    I won’t go back to Schermerhorns restaurant. Got ripped off when buying lobsters… the guy went fishing around in the tank for a few minutes. I asked what he was fishing for..he said for 2 1 and 1/2 lb. lobster. He put them in a bag and they weighed in at 3 lbs 3 oz… gave me the correct price per lb. When I got home and took them out of the bag, one lobster was a cull….one large claw missing. I paid for a lobster, not for a cull, which is cheaper. Will not go back to this place again.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest stories and posts from the Advocate. 

You have Successfully Subscribed!