Epic Chowder Smackdown: Old school fish shop takes top honor

CAROL LOLLIS
Chowder CCarol Lollis | Daily Hampshire Gazette
CAROL LOLLIS

Schermerhorn’s Seafood Restaurant clam chowder, Holyoke Score: 4.5 Price: cup, $3.99; bowl, $4.99

The judges found this chowder deliciously creamy and well-balanced.

Amanda: Everything a clam chowder should be. You could actually smell the clams.

Kristin: The clams were soft and the creamy potato mixed nicely. Buttery fishy goodness.

Lou: A little gritty, but not too gritty. This is a very classic clam chowder done well.

Cal’s Wood-Fired

Grill & Bar clam chowder, West Springfield Score: 3.9 Price: $5

This one surprised the judges with its powerful and complex notes of cheese — Gruyere? Amanda found it “confusing,” but most enjoyed it quite a bit.

Lou: Creamy and clammy, with a good depth of flavor. It felt elegant. Not quite funky, but almost. I mean that in a good way.

Hunter: Not sure that I’d eat a big bowl of it, but it’s surprising and nicely aromatic.

James: I kept wondering if the Swiss had invaded. This one doesn’t work for me.

Smithsonian Cafe and Chowderhouse seafood chowder, Northampton and Hatfield Score: 2.8 Price: cup, $4.25; bowl, $5.50

The panel wasn’t wowed with this soup, citing a sturdy flavor profile, but finding the texture a bit off-putting.

Kristin: Listless. Tastes mass-produced. My chopped veggies are tiny.

Lou: I expect this kind of chowder to be served in most places. It’s not bad, and it’s fairly spiced, but it’s so-so.

Hunter: My clams had a good consistency. I liked that it was on the thicker side. It’s a workman-like chowder.

#5: Captain Jack’s Roadside Shack clam chowder, Easthampton Score: 2.75 Price: cup, $3.25; bowl, $6

This chowder stood out for its bacon — with mixed results.

Amanda: I like bacon, but the bacon overpowers this one. It was pretty much the only thing I could taste.

Lou: Underseasoned, and I couldn’t taste any clams. It could have been a potato chowder for all I know.

James: The upfront salt detracted from the other flavors. Too chewy. This one had a challenging clam.

Ocean Grill & Steakhouse clam chowder, Greenfield Score: 2.5 Price: cup, $4.50; bowl, $5.95

This divisive concoction had some judges patting their bellies and some judges bemused by the balance of flavors.

Kristin: Too fishy.

Pete: Deliciously salty. Almost grimy. Tasted authentic, with a decent amount of clams.

James: Bacon! Land animals don’t belong in chowder.

#6: Paul & Elizabeth’s Restaurant seafood chowder, Northampton Score: 2.2 Price: cup, $3; bowl $4.25

This beach-bummer scored lowest and left the panel unimpressed.

Hunter: The fish was overcooked, and the soup itself is flat and bland. It’s like they forgot to season it.

Kristin: It’s trying too hard to let the fish be the star, but it needs more supporting characters. Simple is not best in this case.

Pete: I did get lots of veggies and a decent amount of fish, so that’s good. I would still add bacon.•

Hunter 
 Styles 
 Photos by 
 Carol Lollis

Author: Hunter Styles Photos by Carol Lollis

Share This Post On

1 Comment

  1. I won’t go back to Schermerhorns restaurant. Got ripped off when buying lobsters… the guy went fishing around in the tank for a few minutes. I asked what he was fishing for..he said for 2 1 and 1/2 lb. lobster. He put them in a bag and they weighed in at 3 lbs 3 oz… gave me the correct price per lb. When I got home and took them out of the bag, one lobster was a cull….one large claw missing. I paid for a lobster, not for a cull, which is cheaper. Will not go back to this place again.

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest stories and posts from the Advocate. 


You have Successfully Subscribed!