Between the Lines: Bottle Bill Massholes

If Mainers can afford a nickel deposit, why can’t we?

Comments (3)
Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Last week I spent a few days in central Maine, where I took my golden retriever for some training. While I had a great time with a bunch of my hunting buddies—both the two- and four-legged varieties—I also absorbed an extra dose of the kind of regional hazing that flatlanders can expect whenever they get friendly with the locals.

The worst of it came when I accidentally tossed a plastic water bottle purchased in Massachusetts into a cardboard box at a Maine rod and gun club. A sign on the box asked folks to donate their nickel deposit bottles and cans to benefit the club.

I wasn’t born in Maine; though both sides of my family have been there for hundreds of years, even if I were to take up full-time residency, I’ll never really be a Mainer. That’s OK, because nowadays Maine is filled with people “from away.” In the new, global economy, a lot of the old, popular knocks on out-of-staters and tourists have softened or disappeared altogether.

But one thing hasn’t changed: Mainers still have a native distrust of people from Massachusetts. If anything, the antipathy may be getting worse. It probably has something to do with the vestigial memory that Maine was once part of the Massachusetts Bay Colony. As Mainers like to say, Massachusetts used to own Maine and seems to be busy buying the state back—“one piece at a time.” Whether we bring a slew of unrealistic expectations or just our shitty driving habits to Maine, we’ve collectively gained a very poor reputation. Hence the nickname “Massholes.”

That’s just what my buddies called me when I came out of my truck with a handful of empty bottles. Some of them had contained fizzy liquid, the nickel deposit on which can be redeemed in Maine. But a few Poland Springs water bottles had sneaked into my pile. Sadly, each one had its label bordered in bright red, the mark of a non-deposit bottle from Massachusetts.

“Can’t throw that in there, ya Masshole!” And so forth.

With a petition drive underway to get an expanded bottle bill on the 2014 ballot, Bay State lawmakers last week held yet another round of hearings on the idea. The pols have been holding such hearings for decades, but inevitably side with bottlers and retailers, who say the deposit is like a tax.

No, it isn’t. The deposit is 100 percent refundable. And, contrary to industry hype, an expanded bottle bill won’t slow the sales of water and juice any more than it slowed the sale of beer and soda. Nor is this a pet idea of the left. Hell, even my gun-toting, pro-business, big government-bashing buddies from Maine support it.

Let’s not be Massholes. Let’s get in line with the rest of New England and do the right thing. Let’s expand the bottle bill.•

Comments (3)
Post a Comment

Tom, did you clutch your pearls and dab your brow with a lace handkerchief when crying: "What will they think of us in Maine?!?"


Posted by Don't drop your monocle on 9.25.13 at 9:34

Even if the expanded bottle bill did slow the sales of water in a plastic bottle (which sadly, it won't) the whole concept of water from questionable souurces sold to people in bottles made of questionable materials is just plain lame. What ever happened to the thermos? Furthermore, municipal publicly-owned water systems need to upgrade so folks can have safe, quality tap water that doesn't taste like the neighbor's swimming pool. This is a public health issue.

Posted by The Enviro Show on 9.26.13 at 8:54

right on tom! in jersey we have a tax on litter to stop the bottle bill. this has went on for nearly 30 years - and with no success. litter all over, heavy tax on residnet and costly recyclingprograms - with bogus numbers. we need a national bottle bill - today!

Posted by alfredo on 9.30.13 at 9:09



New User/Guest?

Find it Here:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

In Satoshi We Trust?
Outside the Cage
How solid is the case for organic and cage-free egg production?
Between the Lines: Practically Organic
Does the organic farming movement make perfect the enemy of good?
Scene Here: The Kitchen Garden Farm
From Our Readers
Profiles in Survival
Young business owners in retail-rich Northampton get along by getting along.
The Burning Question
Neighbors of a proposed wood-burning plant in Springfield cry foul air